Extended descriptions
Table view: Basic | Fixed Header | Scrolled (The basic view is best for screen readers.)
| Reading System | Tests Passed | Detection of aria-details on image (img element) in figure element | Moving to extended description inside figcaption | Detection and utilization of details and summary elements inside figcaption | Detection of aria-details | Moving to extended description next to the image | Detection and utilization of details and summary elements | Detection of aria-details on image (img element) | Linking to extended description at end of chapter | Fallback technique for linking to extended description via text hyperlink | Fallback technique for linking to extended description via image hyperlink | aria-describedby points to an aside in a figcaption | aria-describedby points to an aside at the end of chapter | Block-level image with empty alt and without role="presentation" | Inline graphic with empty alt and without role="presentation" | Block-level image with role="presentation" and empty alt | Inline graphic with role="presentation" and empty alt | Expanding details and ease of reading | Collapsing and pagination |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Online v 2019 (Windows 10)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Desktop Windows v 8 (Windows 7/8/10)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
RedShelf v Cloud-based (Windows 10)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
RedShelf v Cloud-based (Windows 10)
JAWS for Windows screen reader |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
RedShelf v Cloud-based (Windows 10)
JAWS for Windows |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
RedShelf v Cloud-based (Windows 10)
NVDA (April 1) |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
RedShelf v Cloud-based (Windows 10)
NVDA (April 1) |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 4.5.2.151207 (Microsoft Windows 10)
Jaws |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Microsoft Edge v 1809 (Windows 10)
|
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Microsoft Edge v 1809 (Windows 10)
NVDA 2018.4.1 |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Dolphin EasyReader v 7.0.6 (Windows 10)
Jaws 2018 |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Voice Dream Reader v 4.7.1 (iOS 12)
|
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Dolphin EasyReader v 7.06 (Windows 10)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 4.5.6.177.148 (Windows 10)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Dolphin EasyReader v 2.4.449 (Android 9)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Dolphin EasyReader v 2.4.449 (Android 9)
Talkback |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Google Play Books v 5.0.5 (Android 9)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Google Play Books v 5.0.5 (Android 9)
Talkback |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Dolphin EasyReader v 2.3 (iOS 12)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Google Play Books v 5.1.2 (iOS 12.1.3)
|
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Google Play Books v 5.1.2 (iOS 12.1.3)
Voiceover |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf v 4.5.1 (iOS 12.1.3)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Azardi v 43.1 (Windows 10)
NVDA 2018.4.1 with EcoBraille Plus |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Azardi v 43.1 (Windows 10)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Voice Dream v 4.7.1 (iOS 12)
Voiceover |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Apple Books v 4.2.1 (iOS 12)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Apple Books v 4.2.1 (iOS 12)
Voiceover |
10/18 | Supported | Supported | Supported | Supported | Supported | Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Supported | Not Supported | Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Supported | Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported |
|
Apple Books v 1.17 (MacOS )
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Simply Reading v 3.0.7 (Android 9)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Simply Reading v 3.0.7 (Android 9)
Talkback |
2/18 | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Not Supported | Supported | Supported | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Voice Dream v 3.0.32 (Android 9)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Voice Dream v 3.0.32 (Android 9)
Talkback |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Dolphin EasyReader v 2.3 (iOS 12)
Voiceover |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf v 4.5.1 (iOS 12.1.3)
|
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 4.5.10 (iOS 12)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 4.5.10 (iOS 12)
Voiceover |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 4.5.10 (Android 9)
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 4.5.10 (Android 9)
Talkback |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
Adobe Digital Editions v 10.5.10 (MacOS )
None |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Online v Browser/Cloud-based (Windows 10)
JAWS 2019 |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Online v Browser/Cloud-based (Windows 10)
NVDA (April 1, 2018) |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Online v Browser/Cloud-based (Windows 10)
NVDA (April 1) |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Online v Browser/Cloud-based (Windows 10)
JAWS for Windows 2019 |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
RedShelf v Cloud-based (Mac OSX10.14 Mojave 10.14 Mojave)
VoiceOver with gestures and keyboard. |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |
|
VitalSource Bookshelf Online v Browser/Cloud-based (Mac OSX10.14 Mojave 10.14 Mojave)
VoiceOver using gestures and keyboard. |
0/18 | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested | Not Tested |